I was
prompted to write this week’s post after I made a comment that a lot of the
books published by one of the major science fiction publishers in the US seemed
to be awful pulp fiction: full of mad scientists and buff alpha males saving
damsels in distress. I was further prompted by an article where John Marsden,
Australia’s biggest selling young adult novelist, said that publishers were
sick of dystopian novels. So I decided to analyse the 16 science fiction books
listed in a Tor blog post that were to be published in
January.
prompted to write this week’s post after I made a comment that a lot of the
books published by one of the major science fiction publishers in the US seemed
to be awful pulp fiction: full of mad scientists and buff alpha males saving
damsels in distress. I was further prompted by an article where John Marsden,
Australia’s biggest selling young adult novelist, said that publishers were
sick of dystopian novels. So I decided to analyse the 16 science fiction books
listed in a Tor blog post that were to be published in
January.
Of the 16
books listed, one is definitely fantasy, and two others are non-fiction books
about science fiction, so I have removed them from my analysis.
books listed, one is definitely fantasy, and two others are non-fiction books
about science fiction, so I have removed them from my analysis.
Fugitive
X, Gregg Rosenblum (Harper
Teen)
X, Gregg Rosenblum (Harper
Teen)
Concept: A
war against robots who control the world.
war against robots who control the world.
Sub-genre:
Dystopian
Dystopian
Series:
Yes, it is the second book in a series.
Yes, it is the second book in a series.
Market:
Young adult.
Young adult.
Debut
Novel: No, the author had been published before.
Novel: No, the author had been published before.
Nationality
of Author: American.
of Author: American.
Game Slaves, Gard Skinner (Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt)
Mifflin Harcourt)
Concept: Self-aware AIs try to escape from a virutal world/game.
Sub-genre: Cyberpunk
Series: No
Market: Young Adult
Debut Novel: Yes
Nationality of Author: American.
Independent
Study, Joelle Charbonneau (Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt)
Study, Joelle Charbonneau (Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt)
Concept:
After a devastating war, the government tries to erase brutal memories from the
mind of one of its chosen young leaders.
After a devastating war, the government tries to erase brutal memories from the
mind of one of its chosen young leaders.
Sub-genre:
Dystopian
Dystopian
Series:
Second in a series
Second in a series
Market:
Young adult
Young adult
Debut
novel: No.
novel: No.
Nationality
of Author: American.
of Author: American.
Journey Into
the Flame, T.R. Williams (Atira)
the Flame, T.R. Williams (Atira)
Concept: After
a solar storm sends the world dark, the teachings of an ancient book turn the
world around, but the book falls into the wrong hands.
a solar storm sends the world dark, the teachings of an ancient book turn the
world around, but the book falls into the wrong hands.
Sub-genre:
Soft science fiction, could be dystopian
Soft science fiction, could be dystopian
Series: First
in a series
in a series
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: This appears to be his debut novel
novel: This appears to be his debut novel
Nationality
of Author: American.
of Author: American.
C-Monkeys and Gamification Keith
Hollihan
(ChiZine)
Hollihan
(ChiZine)
Two
novellas in the one book.
novellas in the one book.
Concept:
A science fiction pulp fiction magazine
leads a researcher to an island where scientists genetically engineer
salamanders who plan to take over the world.
A science fiction pulp fiction magazine
leads a researcher to an island where scientists genetically engineer
salamanders who plan to take over the world.
Sub-genre:
Pulp fiction
Pulp fiction
Series:
Two novellas make this a series
Two novellas make this a series
Market:
Adult?
Adult?
Debut
novel: No, he appears to have written at least one other novel.
novel: No, he appears to have written at least one other novel.
Nationality:
Born in Canada, lives/lived in the US.
Born in Canada, lives/lived in the US.
Star Road: A
Novel, Matthew J. Costello and Rick Hautala (Thomas Dunne)
Novel, Matthew J. Costello and Rick Hautala (Thomas Dunne)
Concept: An
ex-rebel leader is on a secret mission to the furthest reaches of the galaxy.
ex-rebel leader is on a secret mission to the furthest reaches of the galaxy.
Sub-genre:
Space opera/military
Space opera/military
Series:
Not yet
Not yet
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: Both authors have had other novels published.
novel: Both authors have had other novels published.
Rick
Hautala was a big selling author before he died in March 2013.
Hautala was a big selling author before he died in March 2013.
Mathew J
Costello appears to be American.
Costello appears to be American.
Vitro, Jessica Khoury
(Razorbill)
Concept: Scientists
create superhuman embryos on a secret island. (Not the same one with the ancient
salamanders on it.) Sophie and a hunky pilot investigate.
create superhuman embryos on a secret island. (Not the same one with the ancient
salamanders on it.) Sophie and a hunky pilot investigate.
Sub-genre:
Pulp fiction
Pulp fiction
Series:
Not yet
Not yet
Market: Young
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: No, she has written two other novels
novel: No, she has written two other novels
Nationality:
American.
American.
The Echo, James Smythe (Harper
Voyager)
Concept: Twin
scientists investigate a vast blackness of space where a spaceship disappeared.
scientists investigate a vast blackness of space where a spaceship disappeared.
Sub-genre:
Space Opera
Space Opera
Series:
Yes, this is a sequel
Yes, this is a sequel
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: No, he has written at least three other novels
novel: No, he has written at least three other novels
Nationality:
British – could be Welsh.
British – could be Welsh.
Halo: Mortal
Dictata, Karen Traviss (Tor)
Dictata, Karen Traviss (Tor)
Concept: A
black ops team tries to stop the father of a comrade attacking Earth with
plasma bombs from an orbiting spacecraft.
black ops team tries to stop the father of a comrade attacking Earth with
plasma bombs from an orbiting spacecraft.
Sub-genre:
Military
Military
Series:
Yes, it’s the third novel in a subseries within a series of twelve novels.
Yes, it’s the third novel in a subseries within a series of twelve novels.
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: No, the author has written many novels that are parts of series
including Star Wars.
novel: No, the author has written many novels that are parts of series
including Star Wars.
Nationality:
English.
English.
A Darkling
Sea, James Cambias(Tor)
Sea, James Cambias(Tor)
Concept: A
war breaks out between humans and aliens after human scientists investigate a
planet inhabited by a second alien race.
war breaks out between humans and aliens after human scientists investigate a
planet inhabited by a second alien race.
Sub-genre: First Contact
Series: No
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: Yes
novel: Yes
Nationality:
American.
American.
Lines of
Departure,
Marko Kloos (47North)
Departure,
Marko Kloos (47North)
Concept:
During an interstellar conflict, an officer is reassigned to a ship bound for a
distant colony and crewed by malcontents and troublemakers.
During an interstellar conflict, an officer is reassigned to a ship bound for a
distant colony and crewed by malcontents and troublemakers.
Sub-genre:
Military
Military
Series:
Yes, this is the second novel with the same main character
Yes, this is the second novel with the same main character
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: No
novel: No
Nationality:
German, but now lives in the US.
German, but now lives in the US.
Red Rising, Pierce Brown
(Del Rey)
Concept: A
worker in a mine on a planet discovers he has been deceived by those living
above ground and he rebels.
worker in a mine on a planet discovers he has been deceived by those living
above ground and he rebels.
Sub-genre:
Dystopian.
Dystopian.
Series:
Yes, this is the first book in a trilogy
Yes, this is the first book in a trilogy
Market:
Adult
Adult
Debut
novel: Yes
novel: Yes
Nationality:
American.
American.
Sub-genre
Three of
the books sound dystopian, and another one could be. Three are military, I
would classify two as pulp fiction, two as space operas, one is cyberpunk and
one is first contact. So perhaps there isn’t as much pulp fiction being
released as I feared. I prefer science fiction that explores ideas or puts
characters in harsh situations and we follow their attempts to survive. So I am
glad to see that around a third of the books are dystopian.
Series
Eight of
the 13 books are part of or the start of a series. Wow.
the 13 books are part of or the start of a series. Wow.
Market
Four of
the novels are aimed at young adults, that’s about 30%, a rather high proportion.
Take note John Marsden, two of those four young adult novels appear to be
dystopian.
the novels are aimed at young adults, that’s about 30%, a rather high proportion.
Take note John Marsden, two of those four young adult novels appear to be
dystopian.
Debut
novel
The fact
that many of the books were part of a series meant that there were only four
debut novelists. Considering a new writer’s manuscript has to compete against further
novels from already published authors, I reckon four out of 13 authors debuting
is very good.
that many of the books were part of a series meant that there were only four
debut novelists. Considering a new writer’s manuscript has to compete against further
novels from already published authors, I reckon four out of 13 authors debuting
is very good.
Nationality
Nine of
the authors were American. Two others moved to the US. Two were British.
the authors were American. Two others moved to the US. Two were British.
What About
Me?
As an
Australian, my best chance of being published in the US appears to involve
moving there and writing a dystopian or military trilogy.
Australian, my best chance of being published in the US appears to involve
moving there and writing a dystopian or military trilogy.
In my next blog post I will check out
what science fiction people are actually enjoying reading to see if it matches
what the publishers are publishing.
what science fiction people are actually enjoying reading to see if it matches
what the publishers are publishing.
0 Responses
Very well researched Graham. How do you find out about all this stuff?
It's both interesting and yet very frustrating to me. I finished the first draft of my dystopian novel in 2006. I tried for years to get it out there. I thought I was a little ahead of the game, but now its lagged behind. Thank God I didnt bother with a zombie or vampire novel (not that I ever would) but people who try to follow trends end up in the same position I find myself in.
Having said that, most of these don't sound very inspiring. I think you nailed it when you said you need to move to the U.S. You can also follow every rule and dot point and still come up empty. So much is about timing and luck, and of course, knowing the right person.
Informative, but (for me) depressing. I wish you well on your journey and hope you beat the bastards.
Hi Anthony,
I would like to read your dystopian novel to see what it is like, especially since you are such a good writer.
In my next post, on what readers thought were great science fiction books released in 2013, there's an awful lot of dystopian fiction, so I reckon John Marsden might be wrong.
I have never identified a trend and tried to write to it. Of the five manuscripts I have in various states of completion, three are dystopian, but with very different focuses, another is a space opera (the one I recently completed the first draft of), and the last one, Stalking Tigers,(closest to completion) is thriller set in space. At the moment I am editing a fantasy/sci-fi short story that is narrated by Sam, a Golden Labrador.
But I am finding looking at what publishers are publishing and what readers are reading (which could be quiet different from what they are buying – which might be a further post) very interesting.
Thanks for the compliment Graham.
I think you just have to follow what interests you as the whole process of getting a novel published takes so long that anything could be on the cards by that time. I do think publishers look to cash in on trends which is why they select novels that suit – so I think you just have to keep trying in the hope that eventually what you've written will tick the boxes.
I am not going to bother writing science fiction that does not interest me just to follow a trend. So I will keep on writing my first contact and dystopian novels (although Stalking Tigers is hard to categorise).
I wonder whether writers like James Patterson and Tom Clancy who sub-contracted their writing out actually enjoy what they are writing. They did perhaps at the start but then might have got trapped in a genre probably because of a massive publishing contract.
Very much like the way J K Rowling has gone about escaping from Harry Potter – crime novels under another name, and a social commentary type novel under her name. She obviously loves writing and she has decided to explore other genres.